Our Menu

Featuring the World's Best Apple Pie

Below is a list of our pies. Not all of the pies on our list are baked every day. Call ahead to find out which varieties are available or to request pie to be made.

Pricing

*If picked up in Neosho.

Wholesale Prices Available

All fruit pies are available frozen and unbaked.
You can say you baked it yourself!

The World's Best Crumb Top Apple Pie
Crumb Top Apple

This pie combines the old fashioned taste of apples, cinnamon and sugar, baked in our flaky, REAL butter crust, topped with our signature crumb topping that melts in your mouth. "This is NOT a one piece pie!"


Ozark Berry Pie
Ozark Berry Pie

We start with blueberries, blackberries and raspberries and add apples and spices. We bake this delight in our flaky, REAL butter crust, and top with our delicious signature crumb topping. Berry Yummy!


Traditional Apple Pie
Apple Pie

This pie combines fresh apples, sugar and spices to create an old-fashioned favorite.


Cranberry-Apple Pie
Cranberry Apple

We combine fresh local Golden Delicious and Johnathon Apples with tangy cranberries and spices baked in our flaky, REAL butter crust, and top with our delicious signature crumb topping. A seasonal delight!


Traditional Pumpkin Pie
Traditional Pumpkin Pie

A rich pumpkin custard made with real cream and spices. That's tradition at it's BEST!


Caramel Pecan Pumpkin Pie
Carmel Pecan Pumpkin

Imagine our Traditional Pumpkin Pie with a gorgeous, crunchy brown sugar and pecan topping. This takes it to the next level!


Pecan Pie
Pecan Pie

A Midwest version of the Southern Classic made EXTRA special with beautiful, local, Missouri pecans. We also offer a chocolate variety for those who like an extra kick to their pecan pie.


Our Cream Pies are available year-round. We offer Coconut Cream, Key Lime, German Chocolate

Coconut Cream Pie
Coconut Cream Pie

We make our cream filling the old-fashioned way, with real vanilla and fine coconut. Then we pour it into our flaky, REAL butter crust and send it off with your choice of REAL whipped cream or Meringue.


Pumpkin Muffins
Pumpkin Muffins

Our delicious Pumpkin Muffins are made from scratch and filled with our special cream cheese filling also made from scratch. You will love these morsels any time of year. Minimum 1 dozen order.


Double Chocolate Croissants
Double Chocolate Croissants

Light, flaky croissants drizzled in our own blend of white and semisweet chocolate…Delicious any time of the day! $13.00 per dozen minimum 1 dozen order.


Blueberry Muffins
Blueberry Muffins

Plump, tasty, delicious blueberries mixed into our light, airy muffins topped with our signature crumb topping and a dollop of our handmade cream cheese filling make these the best blueberry muffins you've ever had. Minimum 1 dozen order.


Classic
Classic Cheesecake

Made with the freshest ingredients for a smooth, creamy and delicious experience.


Chocolate Lovers'
Chocolate Lovers' Cheesecake

A true chocolate lover's delight - a luscious chocolate cream made with the finest chocolate and pure cocoa piled into an irresistible chocolate cookie crust.


White Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake
White Chocolate Strawberry Cheesecake

The marriage of an Oreo cookie and creamy cheesecake with just a touch of berries blend to a perfect, luxurious balance on a chocolate cookie crust.


Bailey's Chocolate Chip
Bailey's Chocolate Chip

Smooth, creamy, chocolatey, with a kick. An Oreo cookie crust filled with our special blend of cream, chocolate and Bailey's Irish Cream. Leprechauns would trade their pot of gold for just one bite of this Irish treat.


Cookies and Cream Cheesecake
Cookies and Cream Cheesecake

Crushed cookie crust filled with delectable, fluffy, pastry cream and crushed Oreo Cookies. Then topped with whipped cream & Oreo cookie crumbs.


Lemon Cheescake
Lemon Cheesecake

Luscious, creamy with a slight twang - this cheesecake hits the spot any time of the year.


Frozen Pie Crust
Frozen Pie Crust

After numerous requests, we now offer our delicious, flaky, all natural, handmade pie crusts. You'll win hearts (and tummies) baking your own favorite recipes using these golden gems. (2) 9 inch crusts in disposable tins. $7.95


Each of our pies are baked using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients. We buy local ingredients whenever possible to support local Missouri growers and farmers.

Fundraising Program Available, Take a Look. The Pie Lady

About The Pie Safe

Homage to Our Pies

"Absolutely, positively the best pie I have had, EVER!"

- Les A., Chandler, AZ

"This is NOT a one-piece pie."

- Jim R., Neosho, MO

"My Grandma would be proud."

- S.M. - Carthage, MO

"This pie is to-die-for."

- Jim L. - Neosho, MO

We never use preservatives, stabilizers, artificial flavors or coloring and trans fats/hydrogenated oils."

Catering Now Available, please call (417) 451-0364 for details and pricing.